Schneiderman

ACCESS: Top Secret
Top Contributor
Senior Member
Joined
19 October 2012
Messages
1,984
Reaction score
1,941
Prior to finalising the design of the AW27 Ensign Armstrong Whitworth worked on a number of alternative airliner types
 

Attachments

  • AW project_1 1934.jpg
    AW project_1 1934.jpg
    56.9 KB · Views: 192
  • AW project_2 1934.jpg
    AW project_2 1934.jpg
    49.6 KB · Views: 185
  • AW project_3 1934.jpg
    AW project_3 1934.jpg
    50.8 KB · Views: 176
  • AW project_4 1934.jpg
    AW project_4 1934.jpg
    44.7 KB · Views: 189
The narrowing towards the tail of options 2, 3 and 4 seems a bit excessive wasting potential space at the rear of the aircraft and wings look thick enough to walk an elephant on.
 
Amazing Projects Schneiderman,

but can I ask you that,during middle of 1930s,the Type numbers was appeared,did
those airplanes belong to it or not ?,please see;

http://www.secretprojects.co.uk/forum/index.php/topic,9673.msg254528.html#msg254528
 
What were the seating arrangements, 2 looks like a 1 + 1 while 3 and 4 look like a 1 + 2.
 
hesham said:
but can I ask you that,during middle of 1930s,the Type numbers was appeared,did
those airplanes belong to it or not ?,please see;
There is no indication on the drawings and all the numbers between AW15, Atalanta, and AW27, Ensign, appear to have been assigned to known projects. I suspect that they are early concepts that were not given official project numbers
 
PMN1 said:
What were the seating arrangements, 2 looks like a 1 + 1 while 3 and 4 look like a 1 + 2.

Yes, that is correct
 
PMN1 said:
The narrowing towards the tail of options 2, 3 and 4 seems a bit excessive wasting potential space at the rear of the aircraft and wings look thick enough to walk an elephant on.
The fuselage construction looks to be the same as for the AW15 Atalanta rather than the metal monocoque adopted for the AW27 Ensign.
I also just noticed that the original drawing dates are November 1933, signed off in March 1934.
 
Image from Putnam - Armstrong Whitworth:
AW Genet monoplane.jpg
From, Kites, Birds & Stuff - Armstrong Whitworth Aircraft.
It is usually helpful to provide title and author:
Kites, Birds & Stuff - Armstrong Whitworth Aircraft by P.D. Stemp, Lulu.com 2009

Tapper mentions a scaled-down version of the A.W.XV Atalanta with two [140 hp] AS Genet Major engines, yet his drawing clearly shows four engines. The full-scale AW Atalanta was powered by four 340 hp AS Serval engines. I guess both Tapper and Putnam's editor overlooked that glitch.
Tapper's specifications match those provided (copied, I suspect) by Stemp.
<edit> the same design appears in reply #1, first image
 
Last edited:
So, the cargo aircraft is still an unknown?

Its bigger than a Shorts Skyvan which used two 715hp engines so I cannot see it doing anything but rolling along on the ground on two Genet Majors.
 
Last edited:
Stemp's drawing <edit> now deleted </edit>, copied from Tapper, shows the car ferry, its drawing's caption gives dimensions for the scaled-down Atalanta which turned out to be quadruple-, not twin-engined. Tapper made a mistake in an otherwise very nice read, Stemp repeated Tapper's mistake, compounding the mess by copying the wrong drawing. Stemp wasn't paying attention.

Other than that - everything tickety-boo.
 
Last edited:
In reply #9, Stemp's drawing, copied from Tapper, shows the car ferry, its drawing's caption gives dimensions for the scaled-down Atalanta which turned out to be quadruple-, not twin-engined. Tapper made a mistake in an otherwise very nice read, Stemp repeated Tapper's mistake, compounding the mess by copying the wrong drawing. Stemp wasn't paying attention.

Other than that - everything tickety-boo.

Makes sense.
 
So, the cargo aircraft is still an unknown?

Its bigger than a Shorts Skyvan which used two 715hp engines so I cannot see it doing anything but rolling along on the ground on two Genet Majors.
Away from my bookshelves, but ISTR that's a Britten-Norman freighter design - Mainliner? - (if not that then a grown-up Skyvan), covered in Stuck on the Drawing Board by Richard Payne.
 
Seems to be an error in that source. Quite obviously not a pre-1945 project, I think.
We should go on with it in a thread in the post-war section, if there's the need.
 
Well here is a 2-engine version of the AW15 from an original un-numbered Armstrong Whitworth drawing with a tracing date of March 1934
Excellent. Caption in drawing says two Tiger engines, which makes a lot more sense than two Genet Major for an aircraft this size - length 71 ft 6 in, span 90 ft. The same dimensions as the four engined AW15.
 

Similar threads

Back
Top Bottom