Grey Havoc
ACCESS: USAP
- Joined
- 9 October 2009
- Messages
- 24,500
- Reaction score
- 18,175
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LuMIrHlAf2Q#t=23s
Justo Miranda said:Here![]()
Michel Van said:Syd Mead is the most important Designer of our time.
Stargazer2006 said:Michel Van said:Syd Mead is the most important Designer of our time.
Mead is a highly talented sci-fi illustrator, no doubt, but calling him a "designer" seems inappropriate to me. Has he ever designed anything that actually flew? Any vehicle that was actually driven? Any object that was actually used?
Unless an artist does that, he is only a dreamer. The fact that his dreams are pleasing to the eye, extremely detailed or highly evocative make him one heck of a dreamer, but not a "designer" in my book...
Stargazer2006 said:Michel Van said:Syd Mead is the most important Designer of our time.
Mead is a highly talented sci-fi illustrator, no doubt, but calling him a "designer" seems inappropriate to me. Has he ever designed anything that actually flew? Any vehicle that was actually driven? Any object that was actually used?
Unless an artist does that, he is only a dreamer. The fact that his dreams are pleasing to the eye, extremely detailed or highly evocative make him one heck of a dreamer, but not a "designer" in my book...
Stargazer2006 said:Michel Van said:Syd Mead is the most important Designer of our time.
Mead is a highly talented sci-fi illustrator, no doubt, but calling him a "designer" seems inappropriate to me. Has he ever designed anything that actually flew? Any vehicle that was actually driven? Any object that was actually used?
Unless an artist does that, he is only a dreamer. The fact that his dreams are pleasing to the eye, extremely detailed or highly evocative make him one heck of a dreamer, but not a "designer" in my book...
carmelo said:Where are internet and smartphones?
Stargazer2006 said:Michel Van said:Syd Mead is the most important Designer of our time.
Mead is a highly talented sci-fi illustrator, no doubt, but calling him a "designer" seems inappropriate to me. Has he ever designed anything that actually flew? Any vehicle that was actually driven? Any object that was actually used?
Unless an artist does that, he is only a dreamer. The fact that his dreams are pleasing to the eye, extremely detailed or highly evocative make him one heck of a dreamer, but not a "designer" in my book...
He's an Industrial Designer. That's what they do. After the industrial designer has done his bit it's turned over to the engineers to make it real.
Never said it was a one way street.Stargazer2006 said:Michel Van said:Syd Mead is the most important Designer of our time.
Mead is a highly talented sci-fi illustrator, no doubt, but calling him a "designer" seems inappropriate to me. Has he ever designed anything that actually flew? Any vehicle that was actually driven? Any object that was actually used?
Unless an artist does that, he is only a dreamer. The fact that his dreams are pleasing to the eye, extremely detailed or highly evocative make him one heck of a dreamer, but not a "designer" in my book...
He's an Industrial Designer. That's what they do. After the industrial designer has done his bit it's turned over to the engineers to make it real.
An industrial designer's work many times is taking the invention - the prototype and working it into a design that is marketable. If you have seen the 1983 movie Brainstorm, Natalie Wood's character in it was pretty much an industrial designer.
In Mead's case. sometimes he comes up with something in this speculative work that inspires someone to run with that idea and make it work, then it goes back to him to refine the look.
Well, if your business is to sell things, I would think their opinion would be important. But hey, that's just my opinion.Never get opinions from "senior equity research analysts." Their only question? Will it sell?