Brazil CNNA Aircraft Designations

Apophenia

ACCESS: Top Secret
Senior Member
Joined
25 July 2007
Messages
3,873
Reaction score
3,181
Companhia Nacional de Navegação Aérea (CNNA)

The Companhia Nacional de Navegação Aérea (National Air Navigation Company) was created to operate some form of cargo/passenger service along with the manufacture of airframes. CNNA was established by the Brazilian industrialist Henrique Lage in 1935 but it seems that planning had begun at least two years earlier.

In 1933, Henrique Lage had commissioned a glider - the Avia - designed by Antonio Guedes Muniz and built on Ilha do Viana in the Baía da Guanabara. This 'planador' [1] was built with wood imported from Portugal which may have sparked the later interest in using 'national' woods. In any case, the Avia seems not have been designated and pre-dates the official establishment of CNNA.

The story behind CNNA design staff varies. In some versions told, Guedes Muniz recommended the hiring of Belgian engineer René Marie Vandaele, French designer Marcel del Carli, and other European and Brazilian staff. In other versions of the story, Henrique Lage did the hiring himself in 1933. I find the Guedes Muniz version more plausible ... but pick your favorite.

CNNA Aircraft Designations and Style

CNNA built some earlier Guedes Muniz designs but they retained their 'M' series numbers. With the first original CNNA design in 1940, the designation HL-1 was applied - standing for 'Henrique Lage n°1'. Alas, I am unclear on the definitive designation style - Brazilian sources use HL-1, HL1, and HL 1 ... sometimes within the same publication.

After producing 234 airframes, CNNA closed on 30 November 1948 due to lack of orders. However, the former CNNA engineering office persisted in their work under the new title of the Escritório Técnico de Aeronáutica (or Technical Office of Aeronautics). Oddly, the abbreviation is often given as ETAE. [2] Whether ETA or ETAE, the designs continued the 'HL' designation sequence - despite Henrique Lage having died back in July 1941. [3] The final design was the wooden HL-15 jet fighter concept. Some sources say that ETA/ETAE ceased operations in 1951, others that work on the large HL-10 transport continued at least until 1955.

_________________________________

[1] Planador is the Portuguese word for both glider and sailplane. I don't know which category the 1933 Avia would have fallen into.

[2] An exception is the Army University Press' Military Review (Vol 28, Issue 9) which, under Brazil's Air Industry lists the firm as "Escritório Técnico de Aeronáutica (ETA); private ownership; $300,000 production." Perhaps a simple explanation is that the ETAE acronym is meant to stand for Escritório Técnico de AEronáutica?

[3] One Escritório Técnico de Aeronáutica designation did pop up in hesham's reply #3. Apparantly an alternative designation for the HL-10 was ETAE-11. Why a different type number? Who known?
 
Last edited:
Companhia Nacional de Navegação Aérea (CNNA) Designations

HL-1 -- 1940 Piper Cub clone pilot-trainer. x 131*
- HL-1 : Fabric-covered wood wings, steel-tube fuselage
- HL-1 : Prototype, first flown on 18 June 1940, x 1
- HL-1A: 1940-41 prod'n vers., detail improvements, x 8
- HL-1A: 1 x 65 hp Continental A65 HO4, span 10.70 m
- HL-1B: Lighter (reduced fuel) production vers., x 122
- HL-1B: Tailored for the Diretoria de Aeronáutica Civil
- HL-1C: (??) Variant prototype according to Wiki, x 1
-- * Numbers vary according to source from 123 to 140**
-- ** 123 makes sense if 122 HL-1 all types + 1 x HL-5
-- HL-5 (qv was one-off floatplane HL-1 variant

HL-2 -- 1939-40 2-seat trainer prototype (contentious!)
- HL-2 : Said to be 1939 design* (for 1941, see below)
- HL-2 : Low-winged, very sim. in appearance to HL-3
- HL-2 : 1 x "137 hp Franklin" HO6 engine, span (??) m
-- * By Pierre Clostermann, reputed basis for the HL-6

HL-2 -- (Project) 1941 twin-engined utility transport
- HL-2 : René Marie Vandaele design inspired by Beech*
- HL-2 : 2 x 130-to-200 hp (??) engines, span (??) m
- HL-2 : 6 pax or dedicated Correio Aéreo (Air Mail)
-- * Lines like Beech 18, constr. more akin to AT-10**
-- ** Local wood used for both framing and outer skins
- HL-2 : Constr. begun Aug. 1941 but never completed

HL-3 -- 1942 low-wing 2-seat tandem primary trainer, x 2
- HL-3 : Conceived of by René Vandeale in just one day
- HL-3 : 1 x 75 hp Continental C75 HO4,* span 10.30 m
-- * 2nd prototype fitted with a 65 hp Continental A65
- HL-3 : 1st prototype flown 3 months after conception
- HL-3 : 2nd prototype crashed in Rio's Botafogo Bay
-- Poss. (?) derived from Pierre Clostermann design (?)

HL-4 -- (Project) 194? higher-powered devel. of HL-3
- HL-4: Attempt to remediate problems with the HL-3
- HL-4: 1 x 130 hp (type ??) HO? engine, span 10.30 m

HL-5 -- 19(?) Twin-float HL-1 variant/deriv. prototype, x 1
- HL-5 : Flight-tested but didn't go beyond prototype stage

HL-6 -- 1942 tandem 2-seat military/club trainer, x 45*
- HL-6 : Oct 1942 prototype, unclear on engine type
- HL-6A: 1943, open cockpits, exposed cyl. heads, x 5
- HL-6A: 1 x 135 hp Franklin 6AC HO6, span 9.80 m
- HL-6A: Revised tailplane and eventually end plates
-- https://www.secretprojects.co.uk/attachments/6-png.674400/
-- 3v: http://airwar.ru/image/idop/other2/hl6/hl6-1.gif
- HL-6B: 1944 Carué, opt'l cockpit canopies, x 39
- HL-6B: 1 x 290 hp Lycoming O-290C HO6, span 9.80 m
- HL-6B: More HL-6-like tailplane - but much enlarged
-- http://airwar.ru/image/idop/other2/hl6/hl6-7.jpg
-- * Ministério de Aeronáutica figures say as many as 60

HL-7 -- (Project) Single-engined liaison/utility transport
- HL-7 : 4-5 seat low-winged tourer/comms/light transport
- HL-7 : 1 x (??) hp (??) engine, span (??) m
- HL-7 : Wooden structure, fixed tailwheel landing gear
-- HL-7 with "two engines" perhaps confusion with HL-9?

HL-8 -- Dec 1943 low-wing, fixed-u/c trimotor transport, x 1
- HL-8 : 3 x 130 hp (??) HO(?) engines, span (??) m
- HL-8: 1-ton payload, performed a year+ of flight tests
-- https://www.secretprojects.co.uk/attachments/1-png.654604/
-- https://www.secretprojects.co.uk/threads/need-help-for-c-n-n-a-projects.2961/#post-449754

HL-9 -- (Project) Twin-engined version of HL-8 trimotor
- HL-9 : 2 x (??) hp (??) engines, span (??) m
- HL-9 : Fixed and trousered main undercarriage units
-- https://www.secretprojects.co.uk/attachments/2-png.664669/

HL-10 - (Project) 1955 large 4-engined pax/cargo transport
- HL-10: Low-winged freighter, "similar to the Boeing 307"
- HL-10: 4 x (??) hp engines, span (??) m
-- Constr. begun but "interrupted at an advanced stage"*
-- * Obviously, by then, the HL-10 was an ETAE project
- HL-10: aka ETAE-11, designed by Luiz Felipe Marques

HL-11 - (Project) 195? single-engined HL-8 derivative
- HL-11: Same fuselage and wing as the HL-8 and HL-9
- HL-11: 1 x 450 hp FNM-Wright R-975,* span (??) m
-- Licensed, Rio de Janeiro-built J-6-9 Whirlwind [1]
-- https://www.secretprojects.co.uk/attachments/3-png.664670/

HL-12 - (Project) 195? twin-engined freight transporter
- HL-12: Wooden constr. freighter developed by ETA/ETAE
- HL-12: 2 x 450 hp FNM-Wright R-975,* span (??) m
-- * Whirlwinds were likely only one option

HL-13 - (Project) 195? single-engine 4-seater lightplane
- HL-13: High-winged, said to resemble an enlarged HL-1
- HL-13: 1 x (??) hp (??) engine, span (??) m
-- HL-13 unable to compete with lower-cost US imports

HL-14 - (Project)* 195? single-engine military trainer
- HL-14: Side-by-side 2-seater, retractable tricycle u/c
- HL-14: 1 x (??) hp HO6 engine, span (??) m
-- Prototype said to have been "built and tested" (??)
-- https://www.secretprojects.co.uk/attachments/4-png.664671/

HL-15 - (Project) Compact single-seat fighter jet
- HL-15: Wooden constr., inspired by Lockheed F-80
- HL-15: 1 x (??) lbf (??) turbojet, span (??) m
-- No interest from the Ministério da Aeronáutica
-- https://www.secretprojects.co.uk/attachments/5-png.664672/

_________________________________________________________________


[1] The Fábrica Nacional de Motores (FNM or 'Fê-nê-mê') was founded by Brazil's federal government in 1942 at Duque de Caxias in Rio de Janeiro state. The sole purpose of FNM was to produce aircraft engines in Brazil. To that end, FNM obtained a license from Wright Aeronautical to build Whirlwind radials. Although already considered obsolete, some 50 R-975 engines were produced at Duque de Caxias.

This 'National Engine Factory' was established with US financial incentives and technical assistance in compliance with the Washington Accords. Ironically, easy postwar access to US-built aero-engines killed FNM's raison d'être and the factory was sold to Italian interests and converted to automotive engine production.

According to some Wiki pages on Wright Whirlwinds, FNM license-built both 7-cylinder R-760s and 9-cylinder R-975. This seems to be nonsense. The Wiki claim is 'backed up' by a slightly garbled reference to Wright Aeronautical Division (and Licensee) Shipments, 1920 to 1963 (available through the Aircraft Engine Historical Society). But FNM wasn't even mentioned in that document (indeed, the only non-American licensee listed was P&WC).

_________________________________________________________________

So, lots of gaps in the details and dates. Does anyone have more information on CNNA?
 
Last edited:
Amazing work as usual dear Apophenia,

and may this could be help.
 

Attachments

  • 1.png
    1.png
    362.1 KB · Views: 23
  • 2.png
    2.png
    462.1 KB · Views: 22
  • 3.png
    3.png
    442.5 KB · Views: 22
  • 4.png
    4.png
    484.4 KB · Views: 21
  • 5.png
    5.png
    404.1 KB · Views: 24
  • 6.png
    6.png
    228.2 KB · Views: 25
  • 7.png
    7.png
    473.2 KB · Views: 25
  • 8.png
    8.png
    477.5 KB · Views: 21
  • 9.png
    9.png
    383.2 KB · Views: 23
  • 10.png
    10.png
    440.5 KB · Views: 25
Great stuff ... thanks hesham. I've made suitable additions and changes to my original text.

And that also cleared up my confusion over Vandaele's hiring! He was hired by Guedes Muniz in 1933.
 
It's kind of sad to know that these projects didn't go ahead, unfortunately in Brazil several projects didn't get off the ground but... the thing is to move on and try again at some point
 

Similar threads

Back
Top Bottom