Pluto flyby: New Horizons

Not good news for New Horizons concerning the RTG. I would have thought that the designers would have fitted two RTG's onto New Horizons back when the probe was being designed in the first place.
 
NH is a New Frontiers mission, which places limits on mission cost. And given how limited Pu-238 production is, a second RTG may not have been available, or you'd have had to delay Curiosity's mission by several years.
 
NASA are wanting to do another mission to Pluto as there are a lot of unanswered questions about it concerning the discovery of water, so the next probe will probably be an orbiter that will be bigger than New Horizons and so will have to be powered by two RTGs.
 
NASA are wanting to do another mission to Pluto as there are a lot of unanswered questions about it concerning the discovery of water, so the next probe will probably be an orbiter that will be bigger than New Horizons and so will have to be powered by two RTGs.
There are studies at least. No funding yet though. Fingers crossed.




 

Attachments

  • Howett_6005.pdf
    11 MB · Views: 12
Nice find Rhinocrates, let's wait and see if NASA get's the funding for at least one of the future probe designs. I rather like the sound of the Fusion-Enabled Pluto Orbiter and Lander concept that I think will answer the questions of the discovery of water and how much Pluto has and of course if there are any signs of life on the former planet (now sadly dwarf planet).
 
Story has now reached Space News.

NASA, as part of the planetary science senior review that considered proposals from New Horizons and other spacecraft seeking extended missions, only approved funding for two years, rather than three as requested. The agency elected to fund New Horizons through fiscal year 2024 as part of the planetary science division, then have the mission compete in a separate senior review for the heliophysics division for fiscal year 2025 and beyond.

The agency’s rationale was that the planetary science that New Horizons could do was less compelling than astrophysics and heliophysics. The senior review gave the overall proposal a score of “excellent/very good”, the second-highest possible score, but the planetary portion was rated “very good/good”, two levels lower.

“The proposed Kuiper belt object (KBO) studies are unlikely to dramatically improve the state of knowledge,” the senior review report stated. New Horizons would be able to observe several KBOs at a distance, and at viewing angles not possible from the Earth, but the report concluded that those observations would not be competitive with ground-based observations.

“We think that this is shortsighted,” Stern said. “It was the only mission ever sent and the only mission planned to study the Kuiper Belt, and we’re still there.”

He said that while the mission was invited to submit a proposal to the heliophysics senior review, it has decided not to do so. His concern was that New Horizons would become an “infrastructure” mission for heliophysics without a dedicated science team but instead teams that run the spacecraft’s instruments. “I dub them ‘zombie’ teams.”

“Writing a proposal to walk the plank, if you will, writing a proposal for the entire science team to be disbanded, did not look like something that we wanted to do,” Stern said. “We were afraid that the proposal would be accepted.”

 
“The proposed Kuiper belt object (KBO) studies are unlikely to dramatically improve the state of knowledge,” the senior review report stated. New Horizons would be able to observe several KBOs at a distance, and at viewing angles not possible from the Earth, but the report concluded that those observations would not be competitive with ground-based observations.

It would appear that some no-nothing NASA officials need the proverbial size-12 boot up the arse.
 
This part from the article struck me.

New Horizons takes up a minute part of the overall planetary budget. NASA requested $9.7 million for the mission in its fiscal year 2024 budget proposal, less than 0.3% of the overall planetary science budget of $3.38 billion.

“We need to finish the Kuiper Belt,” Stern said, “We finally got a spacecraft here. We’re going to leave the Kuiper Belt in a few years. Why so impatient over pennies out of the planetary budget?”
 
It's good that Stern is calling out this short-sighted penny-pinching stupidity. Since the New Horizon probe is out there if there is any KBO within its trajectory and remaining delta-V capacity then it should be investigated while it's still possible.
 
Despite an extensive search spanning several years, no KBOs have been found that New Horizons could do a flyby of. So all they can do now is long-range observations using LORRI. That's what the "those observations would not be competitive with ground-based observations" line is about.
 
It is a pity that there are no more KBOs near to New Horizons so that NH would be able to do a flyby, but if they could use LORRI to do a scan of the region then it may find some new KBOs that we do not know about yet.
 
New Horizons is one of the most underrated missions out of many of our recent space programs.
 
New Horizons is one of the most underrated missions out of many of our recent space programs.
New Horizon is the most important mission since Voyager 2 from my perspective.

These days, scientists mostly focus on Mars, and on deep space researches.

While Mars looks more and more to be a dead rock with some ice on it (which is so common in fact), we will maybe never have a chance to visit deepspace or at least not before 10,000 years from now, and I really feel that there is some life forms in the solar system out of Earth.

Let's find it !

Radium
 
Last edited:
Despite an extensive search spanning several years, no KBOs have been found that New Horizons could do a flyby of.

The scanning needs to continue nevertheless because the NH probe IS the only spacecraft in that volume of space and it will be years before another probe is launched and that will take years to get to the Kuiper belt.
 
The long period between a new probe and NH is why the current current mission should continue until NASA can know for sure that there are no more KBOs in the immediate vicinity of NH.
 
Here is what I might do as a bluff:

Pluto and Arrakoth are in the rear view—-and some of the folks at Centauri Dreams are bullish on the COSMIC array that found Voyager’s trace:

I might call a press conference with them and discuss NH being used as a beacon—-one last set of commands to spin the thing like mad while transmitting across the spectrum as a target for COSMIC…ruining any possible use for the droll little men and their magnetometers.

Give them a good scare.
 
It's good that Stern is calling out this short-sighted penny-pinching stupidity. Since the New Horizon probe is out there if there is any KBO within its trajectory and remaining delta-V capacity then it should be investigated while it's still possible.
Also it’s contrary to NASA precedent with such long lived missions which is another baffling thing about the decision.
 
The proposal is not to end the mission, it's to switch from planetary to heliophysics, as was done with the Voyagers.
 
The proposal is not to end the mission, it's to switch from planetary to heliophysics, as was done with the Voyagers.

I understand that however if any KBOs are detected along the probe's trajectory that is within the remaining Delta-V available it should be acted on, from what I understand the NH probe has enough propellant left for one more more fly-by.
 
Last edited:
Perhaps different choice of targets could be had…maybe some hyperbolic Sun-grazers on an outbound leg moving in its general direction.

Due a burn well ahead of time to reach an interception point?
 
Anton Petrov has put out a video about the possibility of NASA cancelling the New Horizon mission:

 
Good News for New Horizons:

"NASA’s New Horizons to Continue Exploring Outer Solar System"

See:


View: https://twitter.com/alanstern/status/1707830560666923048


Thank you NASA, Nicky, and SMD from me on behalf of the entire @NASANewHorizons team! We are excited to continue the exploration of the Kuiper Belt and the outer heliosphere, two amazing science areas NASA is pioneering! #Science #Space #NASA
 
Hopefully in the next few years astronomers can find a KBO that is near enough to the probe's trajectory that can be covered by the remaining propellant (IIRC there's enough propellant left for one more flyby if a KBO is close enough).
 
Now let's see if New Horizon's RTG can last long enough to find another KBO to flyby, there must be literally thousands of unknown KBO's out there in the outer Solar System just waiting for the NH team to discover.
 
View: https://youtu.be/reyasPyncYs


NEW HORIZONS with Alan Stern - NSF Live

NASASpaceflight

22 Oct 2023

In this episode of NSF Live, Dr. Alan Stern joins NSF host John Galloway to discuss the bright future of New Horizons and his upcoming suborbital spaceflight with Virgin Galactic.

Check out Dr. Stern's book: Chasing New Horizons, and support our shows:

NSF Live is NASASpaceflight.com's weekly(ish) show covering the latest (~1 week old) news in spaceflight. It's broadcast live on Sundays at 3 p.m. Eastern. On each show, we rotate through various hosts and special guests.
 
Update on the mission including the search for a new flyby target in the Kuiper Belt.

The PI’s Perspective: Needles in the Cosmic Haystack

New Horizons is healthy and speeding across the Kuiper Belt, nearing a distance of 60 times as far from the Sun as Earth is!

The spacecraft continues to collect round-the-clock data on our Sun’s cocoon in the galaxy, called the heliosphere, and transmit that data, as well as the final data from our flyby of Kuiper Belt object (KBO) Arrokoth, back to Earth.

Since I last wrote in this space, two exciting developments have occurred regarding the mission’s primary goal, which is to explore the Kuiper Belt and the KBOs in it.

The approximate trajectories of NASA’s current and past interstellar spacecraft, including Voyager 1, Voyager 2 and New Horizons. (Credit: NASA/Johns Hopkins APL/SwRI)

The first of those was the publication of exciting new results from our onboard dust counter instrument, which you can find online. It shows that over the past few years, the instrument detected an unexpectedly high number of dust impacts. Why is that so exciting? Because it indicates more dust at greater distances from the Sun than expected, which in turn could be evidence of an extended Kuiper Belt, or even a second Kuiper Belt, lying ahead.

This paper does offer other possibilities for the high dust-impact rate in this part of the solar system, but, a second research paper from the New Horizons team, regarding our groundbased searches for KBOs to study along our trajectory, reports a surprising number of very distant KBOs ahead of us. That leads to a similar conclusion that the Kuiper Belt could be more extended, or even that there could be a second Kuiper Belt, still farther ahead. These new groundbased results have been submitted for scientific peer review but aren’t yet published. However, a summary of them is posted here and here.

Together, these results have ignited renewed interest in the possibility of finding a distant KBO that New Horizons could fly past in the late 2020s or even 2030s. Toward that end, our team has proposed a multiyear KBO flyby target search to NASA.

If approved by NASA, that effort would initially continue the deep, groundbased KBO searches with the Japanese Subaru Telescope we’ve been using, but with more search time and a deeper search enabled by a new, high-throughput filter that the New Horizons project provided to Subaru.

Then, beginning in 2025, we plan to propose to use the even more capable Vera Rubin Observatory (VRO), which is jointly funded by the National Science Foundation and the U.S. Department of Energy, for this search. VRO is a new observatory scheduled to come online in late 2024, and can search even more deeply than Subaru can.

In 2019 New Horizons made the first spacecraft reconnaissance of any Kuiper Belt object (KBO), exploring this small and ancient world called Arrokoth, just 21 miles (33 kilometers) long. (Credit: NASA/Johns Hopkins APL/SwRI)

Later, once NASA’s Roman Space Telescope is launched in 2027 or 2028, we would propose to employ this still even more capable observatory, also with custom machine-learning software and supercomputers to crunch those data.

Our calculations indicate that, given the evidence for an extended Kuiper Belt and very distant KBOs, that this triad of searches might just find New Horizons a second flyby KBO. But the calculations also show that even such a search is a longshot, looking for proverbial needles in the cosmic haystack, and might come up dry.

Nonetheless, we know that the odds of finding a new flyby target are much more remote without this newly envisioned set of searches. We also know that the scientific payoff of another KBO close flyby for planetary science in general are immense. And the New Horizons team is eager to search. We are willing to try everything humanly possible to get to another KBO flyby. If we do succeed, we’ll have hit the jackpot, and will have the ability to once again be firing our engines to intercept a KBO for close up study, just as we did to achieve the 2019 flyby of KBO Arrokoth — the first KBO ever examined by any spacecraft!

Also just ahead for New Horizons is our continuing studies of the Sun’s outer heliosphere, observing KBOs we pass in the distance, and making other scientific measurements that only a spacecraft in the distant Kuiper Belt can make.

New Horizons is in excellent health, and has sufficient fuel and power to continue to explore into the 2040s, at least. By the late 2020s or 2030s, the spacecraft should fly through the heliosphere’s so-called termination shock, which is the precursor to the heliopause and our entry into interstellar space! NASA’s venerable Voyager spacecraft have already studied the termination shock, the heliopause and interstellar space, but New Horizons has more modern sensors aboard, to greatly supplement what the Voyagers could do.

This depiction of the Sun’s heliosphere includes the termination shock that New Horizons will cross in the years ahead, the first of several heliospheric boundaries as our spacecraft approaches interstellar space. (Image credit: NASA/IBEX/Adler Planetarium)

To make all this possible, as our spacecraft’s nuclear battery produces less and less power each year, we plan to uplink new software. That software package is called autonomy and fault protection, and the team is already designing and coding it. After extensive testing, we expect to transmit it to New Horizons using NASA’s Deep Space Network (DSN) of communications antennas. You can learn more about the DSN.)

I’m excited about all of these plans for New Horizons. I’m also excited for us to continue to making scientific discoveries in data we’ve already acquired and the data we’ll collect in 2024. Nearly two-dozen scientific papers with such results, ranging from Kuiper Belt and KBO studies, to heliospheric science, and more, were published in 2023, and a similar number is planned for this year.

Finally, before I close, I want to remind you that we’ve updated our mission website to include new details about New Horizons activities and our extended mission — so check it out when you can, and look for more updates to be posted there!

Well, that’s my update for now. I’ll write again later in the year. In the meantime, I hope you’ll always keep exploring — just as we do!

–Alan Stern
New Horizons Mission Principal Investigator

 

Similar threads

Back
Top Bottom