"speciesist"? Seriously? I have been watching with great disgust as The Usual Suspects are turning over every rock to find more ists.
I somehow doubt Scott was being serious.
You're assuming my seriousness?!?! I'm outraged!
There is, of course, a question of how we view other species. Different cultures have very different views, as do different ethicists and policy makers. Questions like: How close does a species have to be towards us to have some rights (e.g. should we treat Chimps better than Clams)? Does treating other species as having more rights (or value) increase the overall value placed on life (including human life) or decrease it?
Some species should be viewed more highly than others. Dogs and Cats, for instance: they are on Team Human. Dogs, especially (though anybody mistreats a cat, they deserve INSERT HORRIBLE THING HERE), since humans have spent ten thousand years bending them to our will.
Sheep and cows, on the other hand, are not on Team Human. They are our food. And there's nothing wrong with that, factually or morally. If we stopped eating them, there's a good chance they'd go extinct. It's certain that their numbers would plummet. The animals that we ranch are in no risk of extinction.
Then there are question like: Is wiping out an entire species a crime? Is wiping out a whole species a crime that is greater or lesser than murdering one human? Is capital punishment acceptable for ivory poachers? If ivory poachers are heavily armed, should park-rangers be allowed to engage (or should they avoid interfering)?
Ivory/horn poaching threatens extinctions. That's not just "aw, darn, no more rhinos," that's "whoops, the ecosystem is collapsing." So hiring a bunch of post-war Ukrainian nerds to fly drones over poachers and drop grenades on them and leaving the remnants for the buzzards and the jackals is entirely appropriate. Especially given that the whole market for ivory and horn is *stupid.* A lot of the rhino horn market is based on nonsensical "other ways of knowing"-level superstitious claptrap for quack medicines... medicines that would be just as effective if made from barber shop hair trimmings and fingernail clippings. Ivory can be replaced with plastic. And soon enough, "real" horn and ivory should be factory-growable. So wiping out species in order to feed the market of stupid people is unconscionable.
People and philosophy and politics is complicated.
Not really. Some people are just stupid. And philosphy... well,
that one's been covered.
Compared to a whole lot of people, squirrels are just awesome. You can tell that they have actual personalities... unlike a lot of the drones you see flapping their gums about the latest trendy nonsense.